The Easiest Way to Pick a Puppy from a Litter

Puppies are the new addition to any home. They’re adorable, cuddly, and get you more likes on social media than you can handle. There’s just one problem: there are so many of them! How do you pick which puppy is for your family?

At first, they may all seem the same. Don’t be deceived, though. Each puppy will have its own distinct personality and characteristics. It’s critical to choose a puppy that fits your lifestyle and personality. Do not choose a puppy only based on how cute it is or which one comes to you first.

We have gathered the best tips on picking a puppy out of a litter.

Can a dog smile? Many dog trainers and animal behaviorists will say that dogs can’t smile. But I’m not sure they are right.

Different folks may choose to adopt their dog from a different location. The core stages, however, are always the same. You must adhere to their instructions.

Picking a Puppy From a Breeder

When you acquire a puppy from a breeder, there are two options for selecting them.

1. The breeder chooses the puppy for you based on:

  • They know a lot about you
  • Their expertise of other families who have gotten a puppy is invaluable
  • Observing of the puppies
  • Their expertise as a breeder

2. You are permitted to choose your own puppy with some assistance from the breeder.

Breeder Picks

Make sure that the breeder knows about you if you want a puppy. Tell them about your life and what kind of dog you want to get. This way they can choose a good one for you.

You should be asked the following questions by the breeder:

  • Do you have any children?
  • Do you stay at home during the day?
  • Do you prefer a man or a woman?
  • Are you a person who stays busy?
  • What types of activities would you like to do with your pet?
  • Do you have a particular hair type in mind if you’re buying a poodle mix?
  • Are you looking for a playful or laid-back dog?
  • Are you looking for them to be self-sufficient or eager to please?

You Pick

If you can pick a puppy from the litter, you need to know what number you are in line. You will not choose which puppy you receive if you are the last to pay in a deposit; you will receive the remaining dog.

If you pick a puppy, think about what you want in an adult dog. Use the questions above to figure out what you require. Then talk with the breeder about what you’re looking for and let them guide you to the pup that best suits you.

When the puppies are growing up, your breeder should spend time with them. The more time they spend with the puppies, the better they know what each is like. When you are ready to pick a puppy, your breeder will have a good idea of what kind of adult dog it will be.

Your breeder should make sure that you get the right dog.

Picking a Puppy From a Rescue

When you pick a puppy, you get to choose which one. But there are some rules. You may be able to choose from the entire litter if you are the first person to be approved for adoption. If not, you will get to choose which one based on when your approval comes in. And just like with breeders, some rescue groups prefer that they do the picking for you.

Make sure to inform them of your lifestyle and the type of person you are looking for so they can match you appropriately.

Picking a Puppy From a Shelter

Most government-run shelters use a first-come, first-serve approach to dog adoptions. This means that if there are puppies left, you will be able to meet all of them.

Picking a Puppy From a Litter

The technique for selecting a puppy from a litter is the same regardless of where you get your dog.

  • Bring a friend
  • Observe the litter
  • Pick a few pups to meet individually
  • Evaluation of each puppy individually using
  • Cradle Test
  • Touch Sensitivity Test
  • Summons Test
  • Sound Sensitivity Test
  • Vision Test
  • Visual check
  • Bite Response

Bring a Friend

Ask an impartial person to come with you when you plan to pick a puppy from a litter. It’s hard to see all of the puppies in one place, so they can help you decide which one is the best.

Observe the Litter

When you go to a litter, you can watch the puppies for a little while. If any of the puppies are missing, ask if they are gone. Watch how the puppies play together and see who is dominant and shy.

If you have difficulty deciding between these two puppies, ask the breeder or foster mom what they think. These puppies can both come with training problems as they grow up.

Pick a puppy that is friendly, curious, and trusts you. If the pup likes you and wants to be near you, it will smell your feet and legs. It will also want to cuddle with you.

If you see that your dog is afraid of you, it might be because they are not trained. They might have to have more training so they can get better. If the dog gets scared when you come near them, they still might need more training. They might start playing with another dog but don’t worry!

Your Personality Type

Puppies come in a variety of personalities. Look for the following traits to determine each puppy’s personality:

Dominate Pup

Dominate pups may seem friendly at first, but they can also be mean. They might try to hurt others or break out of their cage. Young kids might not like this kind of pup because they try to fight the children for control over things.

Independent Pup

Independent dogs have their own minds. You might come across them doing their own thing. They can be fun to play with, and they are smart, but they will need a lot of training. These dogs may get bored if you train them the same way all the time.

People Pleaser

Some dogs that are people pleasers love being around people. These dogs can form significant bonds with their owners. They can be great family companions with good positive training who are often not left alone in the house.

Relaxed Pup

The relaxed pup might not be interested in you. Sometimes they are not very smart. But they love to play, interact and sleep. They will be a good pet for people who want a more relaxed animal. You can’t get these confused with shy pets. Certain pets are very shy, but the relaxed pup is friendly to you sometimes, even if it doesn’t seem like it at first.

Shy Pup

The shy puppy will not be as confident as their siblings. They may stay in the back of the line or have their head down. A shy pup needs time and patience to get more confident. They are better for people who don’t work and train them every day.

Analyze Each Puppy on Its Own Grounds

Pick one puppy at a time to meet. You can also see how they behave.


Pick up the puppy. Hold them in your arms. Is the puppy having any difficulties? Is she attempting to bite or mouth you? Is she in a good mood? A quiet puppy might be easier to train than one who struggles against being held.

Touch Sensitivity

Hold the puppy. Touch his toes and squeeze them gently. Touch his ears too. The pup should not show any pain or fear if he is good for your family.


First, you should sit or kneel on the ground. Then call the puppy to you. If he doesn’t come, click your tongue or tap the ground to get his attention. If he comes quickly to you, it means that he has a strong attachment to people. But suppose he ignores you and gets distracted. In that case, it may mean that he does not need an experienced trainer because he is independent.

Sound Sensitivity

Do you want to see what your puppy does when they hear a noise? You can do this by clapping your hands behind the pup’s head or dropping a set of keys on the floor. Does he ignore it? Does he get startled by it? A good response for a puppy is to investigate the sound source.


To test a pup’s vision, roll a ball in front of the pup. If he watches it or plays with it, his vision is good.


Puppies that are round are preferable. They should be neither too big nor too thin. Clear and discharge-free eyes, ears, nose, teeth, and gums The coat should be clean with no dirt or debris on it. The puppy’s breathing should also sound okay without coughing or sneezing a lot.

Watch the Puppies

Look at the way the puppy walks and runs. The puppy should move around without limping or seeming stiff or sore. Trouble moving may indicate that the dog has hip or joint issues that could worsen over time. Watch its energy level, too. If it is always bouncing off walls, this is a good dog for an active family who will include it in their activities.

Bite Response

A puppy’s bite is how it will be as an adult. If you test a puppy by letting it bite and then say “Ouch!” they should react with fear or concern, not excitement. Puppies who stop biting when people or dogs show pain are more likely to grow up and control their mouths better. It is normal for puppies to stop biting for a moment but then start again if they hear “Ouch!”

Selecting a Name

Now that you have a dog, it is time to give them a name.

It Is Up To You

Now that you know how to pick a puppy from a litter, it is all up to you. Make sure that you pick the perfect puppy. If they are raised well, they will turn out well too. You need to take care of them by socializing them correctly and with love.

What You Need to Do Before Bringing Home a Puppy

  • Watch for hazards in your house. There are many things you need to watch out for. We talk about them in Puppy Proofing Your Home.
  • We have a class that will tell you what you need to buy for your new puppy. You will find out the 7 most important things to buy and learn tips about what to buy for your pup.
  • You must select whether or not you wish to crate train your dog. They will like this because it is quiet when they are scared, tired, or over-stimulated. But it also keeps the puppy safe and out of trouble when you cannot watch them.

For more information about choosing the right puppy from a litter, click here

Frequently Asked Questions About How to Pick a Puppy From a Litter

Which Puppy Should I Pick From the Litter?

There is a certain way to pick a puppy. Name the puppies in order and call them out from first to last. Then choose the one who is not either of these. It might be good for your family if the dog is easy to train, travel with, manage, and easily adapt to your daily life.

Should You Pick the Biggest Puppy in a Litter?

The breeder should have already socialized and acclimated the dog to human contact when purchasing a puppy. Avoid buying the largest or smallest pup in the litter because there is a chance they might not be healthy. Instead, look at how many puppies are in the litter. Generally, the more puppies there are in a litter, the healthier.

Does Pick of the Litter Matter?

It is possible that you not find a dog that you want in the litter. A good breeder should tell you this and encourage you to wait for another litter or pup. The last pick in the litter might not be bad.

How Do You Pick a Puppy From a Hunting Litter?

When you pick a puppy, you want it to be friendly and outgoing. You want a pup that is not much bigger or smaller than its littermates. You also want a pup that looks at your face.

Who Gets the First Pick of the Litter?

The first time the term “pick of the litter” is used, it means to choose a puppy from a litter of puppies. In some cases, this right is given in exchange for breeding with the mother. Pick the litter is a legal and contractual right to take whichever puppy you want from any litter.

How Many Puppies Is Normal for a First Litter?

The number of puppies in a litter can be anywhere from 1 to 12. On average, it is usually 5-6.

Is There Always a Dominant Puppy in a Litter?

I have mentioned before that just one thing affects how dogs act. This is their level of dominance. All dogs are somewhere on the dominance/submissiveness scale. In a letter, there will be a puppy who will be more dominant than the others, and this is usually clear from birth.

How Do You Choose a Puppy’s Temperament?

Take a Puppy Temperament Testing to choose the perfect puppy of your dreams. You can pick a breed or a few breeds. You can find a breeder you feel you can trust and work with. Before seeing them in person, do some background research on the breeder and dog breeds.

How Many Litters Should a Dog Have?

It is recommended to keep the number of litters for a female dog to three or four total. If you are a good breeder, you will spread out the litter over her years to have puppies.

Who Gets First Pick When Breeding Dogs?

Under a typical breeding contract, the male dog will get something. It might be one or two puppies. But this is not legal advice.

Is It Good to Buy the Runt of the Litter?

Being the smallest puppy in a litter is not always a bad thing. You need to be healthy and grow at an appropriate rate. In this context, the word runt is being used nicely.

Is It Okay to Buy the Smallest Puppy in the Litter?

Small puppies can become normal size dogs. Puppies that are small but survive weaning have no more medical problems than their brothers and sisters. Over time, they will get bigger and eat a lot of food. They will be the same size or get to their genetic potential.

What Is the Volhard Test?

The Volhard “Puppy Aptitude Test or “PAT” is a way to predict what your puppy will be like when it is an adult. The test should be done at 7 weeks old.

How Do I Choose a Dog?

If you want a purebred dog, think about the breed. Do you know what to do if they have the temperament, grooming needs, or health problems? You should also check if your family and lifestyle worked with the dog breed.

How Do I Choose a Hunting Dog?

How can you find a good hunting dog breeding? Ask other hunters who have dogs that you admire. Make sure the dogs are field-bred, not bench or show-bred.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

About Us

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, I get commissions for purchases made through links on this page.